How Chlorine Dioxide Works

How Chlorine Dioxide Works

   (PREFACE: While the author is not a chemist, or a healthcare professional, he has worked extensively for years with the manufacture of sodium chlorite solutions, and chlorine dioxide solutions for consumer use as well as industrial use. He is familiar with  the handling and characteristics of the chemicals mentioned in this article. The author has also talked with 1000's of people who have used chlorine dioxide for a variety of applications. While this article is meant to be informative about the nature and characteristics of Chlorine Dioxide, this article will not address any unapproved or medicinal use of this product.)

The process through which Chlorine Dioxide is generated and used is approved for many applications that can also be applied to common household uses.

 In this article I will try to answer some of the most common questions and misconceptions about  Sodium Chlorite and Chlorine Dioxide, and tackle some of the most often debated statements made about this useful chemical.  

 

CHLORINE DIOXIDE: What it Is and How it Works.

  In the first part of this series we will look at the actual material that Chlorine DIoxide is made from, Sodium Chlorite as well the Chlorine Dioxide it produces.

Chlorine Dioxide is produced from dropping the pH of a solution made from Sodium Chlorite and Distilled water.

 There will be some inert salts that were used as buffers in the raw material, which is usually a technical grade of anhydrous sodium chlorite. This may be in powder or flake form, depending on the manufacturer.

 The amount and type of these inert ingredients can vary depending on the raw material used but will generally not exceed 20% of the Raw Sodium Chlorite Powder.

 Typical inert ingredients found in the raw material are Sodium Sulfate, Sodium Carbonate, and Sodium Chloride (salt).

  There may be traces of Sodium Hydroxide, and Sodium Chlorate left over from the manufacturing process of the raw material.  Industrial Grades for non EPA approved uses may contain traces of lead, mercury, and arsenic.

 

 The term 28% Sodium Chlorite used by many people is a misnomer. It includes the inert salts, as well as the actual sodium chlorite when one uses an 80% raw material. This can vary if one is using a different raw material. For instance, if one use a 90% Sodium Chlorite as a substrate, the 28% figure would produce a different result.

  Sodium Chlorite is not a natural product although some websites would like you to believe it is.. It is a manufactured chemical not found in nature. Sodium Chlorite itself has no real viable uses.

   It is manufactured solely as a precursor to the generation of Chlorine Dioxide. (CLO2). It is most often manufactured  by  by what is known as the Hooker R2 Process.

 Toxic Sodium Chlorate is mixed with Sodium Chloride. Sulfuric Acid is added to this, and chlorine dioxide, as well as chlorine gas is formed. The gases are separated by absorbing the soluble chlorine dioxide in chilled water towers.

 Sodium Hydroxide is used as well as. Hydrogen peroxide is used to form the Sodium Chlorite, and remove Sodium Chlorate . There has been an article circulating for years on eHow and Yahoo answers, about making sodium chlorite from a brine solution through electrolysis, that can be done at home.  This actually produces toxic sodium chlorate and should not be attempted. There is no simple method to produce Sodium Chlorite at home.

Anhydrous Sodium Chlorite and Sodium Chlorite Solution can be safely shipped as opposed to Chlorine Dioxide Gas which can not be shipped safely, or economically. Once on site, the Sodium Chlorite  is put into solution. This solution has a high pH, usually 12 +. An acid is added to lower the pH and Chlorine Dioxide is produced.

 

Chlorine Dioxide

 Chlorine Dioxide is the product of lowering the pH of a sodium chlorite solution with an approved acid.. It exists as a greenish gas at normal temperatures. The concentrated gas being formed in the mixed solution gives it an amber aspect.

  Chlorine Dioxide is a small, volatile molecule, that reacts with other substances by means of oxidation.

 Depending on the use, and how it is formed, it is an FDA and EPA approved pesticide that can be used in food service, municipal water, mold treatment, odor treatment, medical use,  mouthwashes, toothpastes, eyecare, and in personal water treatment products, among other applications.   It is considered to be a more "Earth-Friendly" alternative to many chlorine applications.

 

Isn't Chlorine Dioxide the same as Bleach?

 Bleach is a relative term. Many chemicals including oxidizers such as Hydrogen Peroxide (H2O2), can be considered a bleach.  Bleaching means they remove color, and yes, Chlorine Dioxide will remove color, like most oxidizers,
 One industrial use for Chlorine Dioxide is as a bleach for wood pulp, (used in conjunction with sodium hypochlorite), and as a bleach for flour in some countries including the US. The reason it it used in the paper mills is also because of the fact the chlorine dioxide gas prohibits the growth of bio-film as well as for it's bleaching properties.
 

When people say bleach they usually mean Sodium Hypochlorite (common household bleach), 

The real question is: Is chlorine dioxide(ClO2) the same as chlorine (Cl) or hypochlorite (ClO) . The short answer is a resounding NO!


 However, before we look at why they are so different, let's look at why people tend to equate them

 It does smell a lot like chlorine. It can also irritate the eyes and respiratory system if the concentration is too strong.

 It disinfects, and kills micro-organisms.

 Then of course the name....   Chlorine Dioxide..... and yes, Chlorine dioxide does have a Chlorine atom.

 But.... So does salt, in fact the only elemental difference between table salt, sodium chlorite, and common bleach is the number of oxygen atoms attached to the molecule.

1 Sodium Atom + 1 Chlorine Atom                                    =   NaCl  (Common Salt Molecule)

 1 Sodium Atom + (1 Chlorine Atom +1 Oxygen Atom)    =  NaClO  Sodium Hypochlorite Molecule (Common Bleach)

 1 Sodium Atom + (1 Chlorine Atom + 2 Oxygen Atoms) =  NaClO2  Sodium Chlorite Molecule

 1 Sodium Atom + (1 Chlorine Atom + 3 Oxygen Atoms) =  NaClO3  Sodium Chlorate Molecule

(Toxic, Used to make other chlorine compounds. Used as a pesticide and defoiliant,)

 1 Sodium Atom + (1 Chlorine Atom + 4 Oxygen Atoms) =  NaClO4  Sodium Perchlorate Molecule

(Non reactive electrolyte often used in molecular science for DNA extraction and hybridization.)

  This is to demonstrate the difference a single atom can make in a molecule.

 Pure sodium would ignite in your mouth, and pure chlorine has been used as a chemical weapon, yet table salt, a necessary mineral, is just a combination of the two.
In fact these 2 elements, Sodium and Chlorine make up about .2% of your total body chemistry each.
 

 

Chlorine Dioxide vs Chlorine: What's the difference?

 This is the real focus of the issue, and the answer is really pretty simple. While both kill pathogens well....  Chlorine Dioxide does it differently, and more efficiently, without creating toxic byproducts. Chlorine Dioxide kills by oxidation, whereas Chlorine kills by substitution, (in this case called chlorination).
 
 Chlorine Dioxide has a lower oxidation strength than chlorine, but more than twice the oxidative capacity.  Reduction/Oxidation Strength or "Redox" is a measure of how strongly an oxidizer reacts with with organic material, the higher the redox potential, the more substances the oxidizer will react with. Chlorine Dioxide has a lower redox potential than ozone, chlorine, or hypochlorus acid.  Because of this lower redox potential, Chlorine DIoxide is more selective in what it reacts to.
 Typically Chlorine DIoxide will only react with compounds that have active carbon bonds, sulfides, cyanides, and compounds with reduced iron or manganese. Chlorine has a higher redox, and will react with a wider range of compounds, including ammonia.  Because of this difference Chlorine DIoxide does not create toxic by products like chlorine does. This is why Chlorine is limited as a biocide in it's overall effectiveness as opposed to Chlorine DIoxide.
 
 The higher oxidation capacity means that Chlorine Dioxide will remove 5 electrons from the target, whereas chlorine can only remove 2.  Chlorine will bind to a pathogen, and other chemicals and compunds that may be present.  Chlorine DIoxide being more selective, will not  bind with other compounds.  Because of this capacity, Chlorine Dioxide is more efficient than Chlorine, Ozone, or Hypochlorus Acid when used as a disinfectant.
 After the reaction is complete, Chlorine Dioxide reverts to chloride (salt). Chlorine forms Tri-halomathanes from reaction to ammonia, plus other byproducts from other chemicals and compounds as may be present.

 

How Chlorine Dioxide works on Pathogens

Chlorine dioxide kills pathogens by stopping  protein formation.  Viruses and Bacteria are killed by different methods.  

  • Bacteria is killed through the oxidation process mentioned above.  The chloride dioxide steals five electrons from the amino acid of the targeted pathogen.  The amino acid becomes unable to produce the proteins necessary to maintaining the cell wall. The cell wall collapses and the pathogen dies. 
  • Viruses are killed by the reaction of Chlorine DIoxide to peptone. Peptone is vital to the protein formation of the virus. It becomes unable to function, thus "starving" the virus.
  • Pathogens can't build a resistance to Chlorine Dioxide. Even so called "Superbugs" that are resistant to antibiotics have no defense. Chlorine dioxide attacks these pathogens at the molecular level, not through poisoning.

 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The History of Chlorine Dioxide.

 Chlorine Dioxide was discovered by Sir Humphrey Davy in 1844. The British chemist combined potassium chlorite with sulfuric acid. It will soon be discovered that this green gas would be a more effective disinfectant than chlorine.

  By the 1930's Chlorine dioxide was being used more frequently for disinfecting areas. Because of it's gaseous form, it filled spaces evenly. The volitile gas was impossible to ship safely, so Sodium Chlorite began to manufactured as a relatively safe precursor chemical, and the industries using chlorine dioxide would then generate the gas onsite as needed. Because of Chlorine Dioxide's solubility in water, it starts being used as a water treatment.

  In 1944, Chlorine Dioxide was used  by the City of Niagra New York, to control odor and remove phenols from the river water used as the municipal supply to good effect. The city soon changes to Chlorine Dioxide exclusively. The water is cleaner, tastes better, and has no odor compared to the use of chlorine.

  In 1956 Brussels Belgium makes the switch from Chlorine to Chlorine dioxide for it's municipal water system.

 It is discovered that Chlorine dioxide will destroy algae biofilm, a feat which Chlorine could not accomplish.

 Through the 1960's more cities and swimming pools start to change to Chlorine Dioxide.

 In 1967 The United States Environmental Protection Agency (E.P.A)  registered an aqueous form of Chlorine Dioxide to be used as a sanitizer and disinfectant. Chlorine DIoxide starts being used commercially on fruit and produce  as a sanitizer.

  In the 70's and 80's The EPA began reccomending Chlorine DIoxide over Chlorine for water treatment and other applications. This was due to the fact that because of their different chemical properties, Chlorine Dioxide was more efficient, and did not produce toxic trihalomethanes like chlorine.

 In 1988 the EPA registered Chlorine Dioxide as a sterilizer approved for hospitals, laboratories, and healthcare facilities

 In 2001 FEMA and other government agencies use Chlorine Dioxide to to decontaminate buildings contaminated with Anthrax  The Chlorine Dioxide was completely effective against the tiny Anthrax Spores. The buildings, walls and furnishings suffered no damage from the treatment.

 In 2005 FEMA again uses Chlorine DIoxide. This time to eradicate mold from damage caused by Hurricane Katrina. A restaurant in New Orleans was able to re-open after being treated for just 12 hours without major repair.

 In 2006, a man named Jim Humble releases a book called "Breakthrough - The Miracle Mineral Supplement of the 21st Century" in which he details that in desperation, he used the sodium chlorite solution in a chlorine dioxide water treatment product in an attempt to alleviate a man's severe malaria symptoms. Jim Humble claims that the man was in fact cured. Jim went on recount many other illnesses he has discovered that chlorine dioxide could be used for. He develops MMS which is a system to generate small amounts of chlorine dioxide at home.

In 2010  the United States Food and Drug Administration issue a warning on using  MMS according to the JIm Humble protocols. They label it as industrial bleach.  

In the mean time they will have approved the use of Chlorine Dioxide for use in mouthwashes, toothpastes, and as a food service disinfectant among other uses, citing it as being a better alternative than chlorine.

The products, uses, and applications for Chlorine DIoxide continue to grow. More and more mainstream health and home related products are using chlorine dioxide.


Chlorine Dioxide Biocidal Spectrum

As mentioned above, Chlorine Dioxide in different products has been registered since 1988 as a sterlizer .

 The  EPA definifition of a sterlizer is the ability "to destroy or eliminate all forms of microbial life including fungi, viruses, and  all forms of bacteria and their spores," 

More specific tests have been done that prove Chlorine Dioxide's ability to destroy the following:

         

BACTERIA
     
Blakeslea trispora
      Bordetella bronchiseptica
      Brucella suis
      Burkholderia mallei
      Burkholderia pseudomallei
      Campylobacter jejuni
      Clostridium botulinum 
      Corynebacterium bovis 
      Coxiella burneti (Q fever)
      E. coli ATCC 11229
      E. coli ATCC 51739
      E. coli K12
      E. coli O157:H7 13B88
      E. coli O157:H7 204P
      E. coli O157:H7 ATCC 43895
      E. coli O157:H7 EDL933
      E. coli O157:H7 G5303      E. coli O157:H7 C7927
      Erwinia carotovora 
      Franscicella tularensis
      Fusarium sambucinum 
      Fusarium solani var. coeruleum 
      Helicobacter pylori
      Helminthosporium solani
      Klebsiella pneumonia
      Lactobacillus acidophilus NRRL B1910
      Lactobacillus brevis
      Lactobacillus buchneri
      Lactobacillus plantarum
      Legionella
      Legionella pneumophila
      Leuconostoc citreum TPB85
      Leuconostoc mesenteroides      Listeria innocua ATCC 33090
      Listeria monocytogenes F4248
      Listeria monocytogenes F5069
      Listeria monocytogenes LCDC
      Listeria monocytogenes LCDC
      
      Listeria monocytogenes Scott A
      Methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA)
      Multiple Drug Resistant Salmonella typhimurium (MDRS)
      Mycobacterium bovis 
      Mycobacterium fortuitum
      Pediococcus acidilactici PH3
      Pseudomonas aeruginosa
      Pseudomonas aeruginosa
      Salmonella
      Salmonella spp.
      Salmonella Agona
      Salmonella Anatum Group E
      Salmonella Choleraesins ATCC 13076
      Salmonella choleraesuis
      Salmonella Enterica (PT30) BAA
      Salmonella Enterica S. Enteritidis
      Salmonella Enterica S. Javiana 
      Salmonella Enterica S. Montevideo      Salmonella Enteritidis E190
      Salmonella Javiana
      Salmonella newport
      Salmonella Typhimurium C133117
      Salmonella Anatum Group E
      Shigella
      Staphylococcus aureus
      Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923
      Staphylococcus faecalis
      ATCC 344
      Tuberculosis
      Vancomycin
      resistant Enterococcus faecalis (VRE)
      Vibrio strain Da
      Vibrio strain Sr      Yersinia enterocolitica
      Yersinia pestis
      Yersinia ruckerii ATCC 29473
      
      VIRUSES
     
Adenovirus Type 40

      Calicivirus
      Canine Parvovirus
      Coronavirus
      Feline Calici Virus
      Foot and Mouth disease 
      Hantavirus
      Hepatitis A Virus
      Hepatitis B Virus
      Hepatitis C Virus
      Human coronavirus 
      Human Immunodeficiency Virus
      Human Rotavirus type 2 (HRV)
      Influenza A
      Minute Virus of Mouse (Parovirus) (MVMi)
      Minute Virus of Mouse (Parovirus)(MVMp)
      Mouse Hepatitis Virus (MHVA59)
      Mouse Hepatitis Virus (MHVJHM)
      Mouse Parvovirus type 1 (MPV1)
      Murine Parainfluenza Virus Type 1 
      Newcastle Disease Virus      Norwalk Virus
      Poliovirus
      Rotavirus
      Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) 
      Coronavirus
      Sialodscryoadenitis Virus 
      (Coronavirus)(SDAV)
      Simian rotavirus SA
      Theiler’s Mouse Encephalomyelitis Virus(TMEV)
      Vaccinia Virus
     
      BACTERIAL SPORES
     
      
      Alicyclobacillus acidoterrestris
      Bacillus coagulans
      Bacillus anthracis
      Bacillus anthracis Ames
      Bacillus atrophaeus
      Bacillus atrophaeus ATCC 49337
      Bacillus megaterium
      Bacillus polymyxa
      Bacillus pumilus ATCC 27142
      Bacillus pumilus ATCC 27147
      Bacillus subtillis ATCC 9372
      Bacillus subtillis ATCC 19659
      Bacillus subtillis 5230
Bacillus thuringiensis

      Clostridium. sporogenes ATCC 19404
      Geobacillus stearothermophilus ATCC 12980
      Geobacillus stearothermophilus ATCC 7953
      Geobacillus stearothermophilus VHP
     
      PROTEZOA

      
      Chironomid larvae
      Cryptosporidium
      Cryptosporidium parvum Oocysts
      Cyclospora cayetanensis oocysts
      Giardia
      Encephalitozoon intestinalis
     
      
MICROSPORIDA
      Encephalitozoon intestinalis 
FUNGUS/MOLD/YEAST
     
Alternaria alternata
Aspergillus aeneus
Aspergillus aurolatus
Aspergillus brunneo uniseriatus
Aspergillus caespitosus
Aspergillus cervinus
Aspergillus clavatonanicus
Aspergillus clavatus
Aspergillus egyptiacus
Aspergillus elongatus
Aspergillus fischeri
Aspergillus fumigatus
Aspergillus giganteus
Aspergillus longivesica
Aspergillus niger
Aspergillus ochraceus
Aspergillus parvathecius
Aspergillus sydowii
Aspergillus unguis
Aspergillus ustus
Aspergillus versicolor
Botrytis species
Candida spp.
Candida albicans
Candida dubliniensis
Candida maltosa
Candida parapsilosis
Candida sake
Candida sojae
Candida spp.
Candida tropicalis
Candida viswanathil
Chaetomium globosum
Cladosporium cladosporioides
Debaryomyces etchellsii
Eurotium spp.
Fusarium solani
Lodderomyces elongisporus
Mucor circinelloides
Mucor flavus
Mucor indicus
Mucor mucedo
Mucor rademosus
Mucor ramosissimus
Mucor saturnus
Penicillium chrysogenum
Penicillium digitatum
Penicillium herquei
Penicillium spp.
Phormidium boneri
Pichia pastoris
Poitrasia circinans
Rhizopus oryzae
Roridin A
Saccharomyces cerevisiae
Stachybotrys chartarum mentag
Verrucarin A
     
      BETA LACTAM ANTIBIOTICS
Amoxicillin
Amplicillin
Cefadroxil
Cefazolin
Cephalexin
Imipenem
Penicillin G
Penicillin V
     
      CHEMICAL DECONTAMINATION
Mustard Gas
Ricin Toxin
dihydronicotinamide adenine dinucleotide
microcystin LR (MCLR)
cylindrospermopsin (CYN)
      

Keep in mind this is not the full spectrum, but specific tests done against many of the most common pathogens. Included in this list are MRSA,  HIV, E.Coli, Staph, Anthrax, Salmonella, Parvo, Aspergillus, Candida, and many other pathogens that most people will have contact with through thier lives. Chlorine Dioxide when used as a water and surface treatment, vegetable rinse, and environmental cleaner, can help keep your home a cleaner, safer place than using chlorine based products.